Physical Cash Vs. Escrow Services in Private Car Transactions

The main difference between physical cash and escrow services for private car transactions is that physical cash is risky compared to escrow. While physical cash is just a payment method, escrow companies manage the payment and sale conditions so both parties are satisfied.

Learn about physical cash and escrow companies for private-party car transactions. Then, we’ll introduce you to a payment method that is as fast and final as physical cash with the trust and assurance of escrow.

Why Do People Pay With Physical Cash?

Physical cash has a long history, and people innately feel comfortable with it, especially in smaller amounts. Here are the situations in which cold hard cash works well as a payment method:

  • Low-dollar transactions: It doesn’t take much time or effort to count and verify a couple thousand dollars.
  • Transactions between trusted parties: In an exchange between trusted family members or friends, cash is straightforward and pretty quick.
  • Quick or spontaneous transactions: Some sellers make it clear that they are getting rid of an item as soon as possible. If the buyer has the cash on hand, they can jump on a bargain.

What Are the Downsides of Physical Cash?

The advantages of physical cash don’t carry over into high-dollar transactions. When a lot of money is on the line, the speed and convenience of cash disappear.

  • Physical currency: Actual cash can be lost, destroyed, or stolen. A freak accident, an open car window, or a criminal counterparty can ruin the transaction.
  • Fraud risk: Professional criminals create convincing forgeries and pass them to sellers. About 1 in every 10,000 bills is counterfeit, so even an honest buyer might pay with a fake bill.
  • Somewhat slow: Since all bills need to be verified and counted, cash deals can be quite time consuming and awkward.

These downsides make physical cash a clunky payment method for high-value transactions. But there’s another downside to cash that’s shared with most payment methods.

The Private-Party Trust Problem

Within private-party car transactions, there is an inherent trust problem. The buyer doesn’t want to pay for the car until they’ve received the title, and the seller doesn’t want to transfer ownership until they’ve been paid for the car. This catch-22 can’t be resolved by most payment methods alone, so both parties need some outside help.

The Role of Escrow Companies

Escrow companies act as neutral third parties in private car transactions. The buyer transfers payment to the escrow where it is held until the conditions of the transaction have been met. Then, the escrow releases payment to the seller. Here’s the general escrow process:

  1. The escrow parties agree on the sale terms.
  2. The buyer sends their money to the escrow service.
  3. The escrow service notifies the seller that funds have been received.
  4. The seller performs the transfer of title and gives the keys to the buyer.
  5. The buyer verifies that they have ownership of the vehicle.
  6. The escrow service releases the funds to the seller.

Escrow services solve the trust problem by creating assurance that both escrow parties will follow through on the deal.

What’s Wrong With Escrow Services?

Escrow services serve their purpose in high-dollar private transactions, but they’re not without some drawbacks:

  • Hassle: You’re bringing a third party into the transaction. This increases the complexity and lengthens the time frame. You have more inconvenience, more coordination of details between three parties, and more details to manage. It’s the opposite of convenience.
  • Delay: Forget on-the-spot transactions. Both parties have to submit bank details and undergo identity verification. The buyer needs to make the money transfer, and the money undergoes an inspection period. The deal will take at least one or two business days.
  • Fees: Escrow services are expensive for large sums of money. Most charge a percentage of the transaction value. Expect to pay hundreds of dollars or more for escrow.
  • Fraud potential: Scammers set up fake escrow websites to trick sellers into releasing their vehicle using fake payment confirmations. While rare, sellers need to independently verify the escrow service before continuing the transaction.

Escrow transactions are safe, but they are the opposite of physical cash: slow, expensive, and complex. The good news is that you don’t need to choose between one or the other anymore.

DealNow: Escrow-Like Safeguards With Lightning-Fast Speed

DealNow is your new solution for private-party car transactions. It facilitates secure, instant money transfers from the convenience of your mobile device. Here’s why it’s better than cash or escrow for private auto transactions:

  • Escrow-like safeguards: We’re not an escrow service, but we solve the trust problem just like they do. Both parties sign a legally binding digital bill of sale before payment. Buyer and seller can complete the transaction with assurance they’ll get what they want.
  • Instant payment: No more waiting days for funds to clear or escrow periods to end.
  • No payment limits: Just like cash and escrow, you can send or receive any amount. But you won’t have to wait through tedious counts and verifications.
  • Cost effective: DealNow charges a low flat fee, not a percentage of your transaction.
  • Enhanced security: DealNow verifies the identities of buyers and sellers, significantly reducing the risk of fraud.
  • 24/7 availability: Our service is available 24/7 any day of the year, unlike traditional banks or escrow companies.
  • Secure communication: DealNow’s in-app messaging keeps your personal contact information private while providing a record of all communications.
  • In-app features: Rather than coordinating with a third party, you and the buyer have all of DealNow’s solutions at your fingertips. Sellers enjoy funds buyer fund verification, and buyers can order title checks, vehicle history reports, and mechanical inspections from within the app.
  • Long-distance made easy: Buying or selling a car long distance has never been easier. All of our features combine to streamline long-distance car transactions. The inspector acts as the buyer’s agent, completing the translation and coordinating with the shipping company.
  •  

With DealNow, you’re not just getting escrow-like security—you’re getting a complete, high-speed, digital payment platform for car transactions.

DealNow, Physical Cash, and Escrow

The DealNow advantage is easy to see through a side-by-side comparison:

DealNow Traditional escrow Physical cash
Cost
Flat fee
Typically 1% to 3% of the sale price
Free
Maximum sale value
Unlimited
Varies by service
Unlimited
Payment speed
Instant
Several days, sometimes longer
Instant, but requires withdrawal, counting, verification, and deposit
Availability
24/7/365
Business hours only
24/7/365, withdrawal and deposit during business hours only
Buyer-seller verification
Built-in identity verification
Requires multi-party coordination
No verification
Communication
Direct and secure in-app messaging
Complex three-way communication, often exposing personal info
No communication
Paperwork
Digital, automated
Often requires significant physical paperwork
No paperwork, requires a paper bill of sale
Mobile app
Yes
Varies by service
No
Geographic reach
Nationwide (US)
Nationwide (US)
Nationwide (US)
Additional features
Funds verification, title check, vehicle history report, mechanical inspection, insurance, shipping, and financing
None
None

DealNow is more than a payment method or an escrow service—without the downsides.

What Does a DealNow Transaction Look Like?

We’ve designed the DealNow app to make selling or buying a car as smooth and fast as possible. Here’s what a typical transaction look like:

  1. Buyer or seller creates a DealNow dealroom.
  2. They invite the other party.
  3. Both parties undergo ID verification.
  4. The buyer verifies their funds.
  5. The seller sets their availability through the app.
  6. Buyer and seller meet for the inspection and test drive.
  7. Both parties sign bills of sale.
  8. The buyer sends instant payment.
  9. The seller releases the car title and hands over the keys.

The whole deal can be wrapped up in an hour or so on a Sunday afternoon. If you’re ready to simplify your next auto transaction, you’re ready for DealNow.

Escrow Services Vs. Physical Cash FAQ

How much does Escrow.com charge for transactions?

Escrow.com charges:

  • 3.25% + 3.05% processing fee for transactions up to $5k
  • $162.50 + 0.26% for $5k–$25k
  • 0.89% for transactions over $25k

On a $20,000 car, you could be paying over $500 in fees. 

In contrast, DealNow uses a simple flat fee structure, potentially saving you hundreds of dollars on larger transactions.

The safest payment method when buying or selling a car is one that provides security, speed, and verification for both parties. While traditional methods such as physical cash, personal or cashier’s checks, or escrow services are popular, DealNow offers a modern, efficient solution.

DealNow combines the security of escrow with instant digital payments. It verifies buyer and seller identities, provides a secure platform for the transaction, and enables immediate payment upon deal completion. This eliminates risks associated with cash (theft, counterfeit) and checks (bouncing) while avoiding the delays of traditional escrow.

The payment of escrow fees depends on the agreement between the buyer and the seller. In most cases, the buyer pays the escrow fees, but sometimes the cost is split between both parties. In other cases, the seller might agree to cover the fees to make the deal more attractive to potential buyers.

With DealNow, our flat fee structure makes it easier for parties to agree on fee payments without significantly impacting the overall transaction cost. This simplifies negotiations and helps private buyers and sellers focus on the core aspects of the deal.

Cash money might not be the best payment method, but it’s better than many others. Here are some payment types to avoid:

  • Credit cards: Most sellers don’t have the equipment or software to accept credit cards. For a private-party car deal, a third-party intermediary, such as Stripe, will eat up a decent chunk of the transaction with processing fees.
  • Personal check: Most sellers won’t accept these because of fraud and the risk of a bounced check. If they do accept it, they’ll wait until it clears to finish the sale—which is a no-go for many buyers.
  • Peer-to-peer payment apps: PayPal, Venmo, Apple Cash, and other payment apps are great for small purchases, but they have transaction limits and/or processing fees that limit them for high-dollar transactions.
  • Cryptocurrency: Market volatility, complex conversion processes, conversion fees, and other issues plague crypto. 


Physical cash is better than the above methods for a large transaction, but it’s still inconvenient and risky, as we’ve seen. DealNow lets the buyer send instant digital cash to the seller.

Escrow services are not free. Traditional escrow services typically charge a percentage of the transaction value, which can be significant for high-value cars.

DealNow provides escrow-like security that is more convenient and comes at a lower cost.

You don’t need an escrow to buy or sell a car. Some people prefer traditional methods such as cash, personal checks, cashier’s checks, credit card payments, or wire transfers. Others may avoid escrow due to its fees and complexity.

The alternatives can be risky. Cash transactions are vulnerable to theft or counterfeiting, skilled forgers make counterfeit checks, and bank transfers require the seller to disclose sensitive bank account information to a stranger.

DealNow combines the security of escrow with the speed of digital transactions, all without fees. It’s designed to make secure, private-party vehicle sales accessible to everyone.

An escrow agreement is a legally binding contract. Once all parties sign it, they’re obligated to follow the terms outlined in the agreement. This is part of what makes escrow businesses a secure option for private-party car sales.

DealNow Test Form

Add a descriptive message telling what your visitor is signing up for here.

Join the waitlist!

Be the first to know when DealNow for dealers goes live.

Interested in*
Get early access!

Be the first to know when DealNow for dealers goes live.

Interested in*
Join the waitlist!

Be the first to know when DealNow for dealers goes live.

Interested in*