Is Venmo a Good Way to Exchange Funds in Private Car Transactions?

Venmo just doesn’t cut it for most car deals. With its $4,999.99 weekly limit, it’s useless unless you’re buying a clunker. It’s a shame because everyone loves Venmo’s simplicity and instant fund transfers. 

If you’ve been wishing there was a Venmo-like alternative, built specifically for high-dollar car transactions, you’re in luck. Keep reading—but first, a bit more about Venmo.

How Venmo Works

Venmo is a peer-to-peer mobile payment app for small, casual transactions between friends and family. Here’s a quick rundown of how it works:

  • Account setup: Both parties create a Venmo account and link it to their bank account or debit card.
  • Sending money: The buyer opens the Venmo app and selects the recipient.They enter the amount to send. The buyer confirms the transaction and sends the money to the seller.
  • Receiving funds: The seller gets an immediate notification they’ve received the funds to their Venmo balance.

For splitting the cost of a night out, Venmo is great. But for a car? It’s technically possible, but not at all practical.

Venmo Doesn’t Cut It For Car Transactions

Venmo is  fast, easy to use, and doesn’t charge fees for moving money between people. But there’s a catch—actually, several catches:

  1. Low transfer limits: Venmo caps weekly transfers at $4,999.99. For most cars, the buyer would need to stretch payments over multiple weeks, which is a dealbreaker.
  2. No identity verification: Venmo doesn’t verify the identity of its users beyond basic account setup. The world of private-party car transactions is riddled with scammers, who usually operate under aliases. Buyers and sellers need a way to vet one another and verify one another’s identity. .
  3. Potential for scams: Because it lacks robust security measures,  Venmo is a preferred payment avenue of scammers. There have been cases of buyers using stolen credit cards to fund Venmo accounts, leaving sellers in the lurch when the transaction is reversed.

If Only Venmo Were More Robust for Car Transactions

Vehicle transactions are a different beast than other transaction types, and they need a robust payment gateway that can handle their nuances, complexities, and large sums of money. To complete private-party car deals safely and efficiently, buyers and sellers need a payment app built to their unique needs. 

Need Does Venmo have it? Explanation
Instant transfers
Yes
Instant transfers lubricate the transaction process and eliminate hassle and stress.
No (or very low) fees
Yes
Venmo does not charge for fund transfers.
User-friendly mobile app
Yes
Venmo’s mobile app is intuitive and easy.
Identity verification
No
Scammers love secrecy. Legitimate buyers and sellers need their counterparty verified to eliminate fraud.
Title check
No
Wouldn’t it be nice if a buyer could order a title check from their payment app and avoid branded titles and stolen vehicles?
High-dollar transactions
No
A proper car payment app should allow $30k, $300k, or $3M per transaction. With its $4,999.99 weekly limit, Venmo is a lightweight.
In-app transactional workflow
No
Car transactions are complicated and high-stakes. They need a process that takes the buyer and seller through the different stages of the transaction and makes it easy for them.
Available around the clock
Yes
Venmo is available 24/7/365. Whenever you’re ready, it’s ready.
In-app signing of the bill of sale
No
Buyer and seller find themselves locked in a catch-22 (more on this below). A digital bill of sale would break the stalemate.
Add-on services
No
Buyers and sellers often need additional services (professional car photography, car transport, etc). What if they could order those from the same app they used for the transaction itself?

We think every buyer and seller should have all the above capabilities in their pocket. But before we get into how DealNow provides all of this and more, we need to discuss one of the biggest sources of friction in private-party car sales: the catch-22 of trust between strangers.

The Catch-22 of Trust Between Strangers

When two strangers come together for a car transaction, they don’t trust one another. Not that they explicitly distrust each other, but neither party wants to be a dupe. Here are their respective concerns:

  • The buyer doesn’t want to part with their money until they get the car.
  • The seller doesn’t want to sign over the car until they get paid.

Neither wants to be a victim of a bad actor who escapes with both money and car, leaving them in the lurch. While everyone recognizes this as a fairly unlikely scenario, it’s not worth the risk when dealing with large amounts of money.

The conflicting imperatives of buyer and seller create an impasse. Here are two common solutions people have used to overcome it:

  • Use an escrow company: effective, but also cumbersome and expensive
  • Write up documentation in advance that holds each party to their side of the bargain: effective if the paperwork is done properly

DealNow overcomes the catch-22 in the following ways:

  1. Identity verification assures each party that their counterparty is operating under their legal name and not an alias (scammers love aliases).
  2. An official state bill of sale, electronically signed and countersigned by both parties in their respective DealNow mobile apps, assures the buyer that they are legally protected to send funds to the seller. Should the seller default on signing over the car after getting paid, the seller would be liable in a court of law. 
  3. Instant receipt of funds into the seller’s DealNow account allows the transaction to conclude on the spot (delays exacerbate the catch-22 by introducing increased uncertainty).

A Beefier, Better Payment App

Remember that table of needs we discussed earlier? DealNow addresses each one, combining Venmo’s best features with additional safeguards tailored for high-value vehicle transactions:

  • Instant transfers: Like Venmo, funds arrive in the seller’s account the moment the buyer sends them.
  • No fees for fund transfers: DealNow charges a flat fee per transaction, not a percentage of the sale price.
  • High-dollar transactions: Unlike Venmo’s $4,999.99 weekly limit, DealNow handles transactions of any size.
  • Title check: Buyers can order an optional title check directly through the app.
  • In-app transactional workflow: DealNow guides users through each step of the car sale process.
  • 24/7 availability: Like Venmo, DealNow is ready whenever you are.
  • Digital bill of sale: Both parties sign legally binding documentation in the app.
  • Add-on services: Need a professional photographer or car transport? Order these services—and many more—right in the app.

DealNow retains Venmo’s simplicity but adds the robust features needed for safe, efficient car transactions. It’s the solution both buyers and sellers have been waiting for.

Payments FAQ

What is the safest payment method when selling a car?

The safest payment method when selling a car is DealNow. Unlike Venmo, DealNow does instantaneous, verified transfers of any amount directly between seller and the buyer.

DealNow’s platform promotes secure transactions by:

  • Verifying both parties’ identities
  • Confirming the buyer has sufficient funds before the transaction
  • Providing a digital bill of sale
  • Enabling instant transfers without transaction limits

With DealNow, you get Venmo-like convenience with a transactional dealflow and no limits on funds transfer. Funds are held in FDIC-insured accounts with easy offboarding to your regular bank.

Personal checks are the least secure payment method for sellers, especially in high-value transactions such as car sales. Here’s why:

  • Bounced checks: There’s no guarantee of sufficient funds in the buyer’s account.
  • Delayed verification: It can take days for a check to clear, leaving you in limbo.
  • Fraud risk: Fake or altered checks can be difficult to spot.

Venmo is much safer than physical cash. Physical cash is a hassle to withdraw from the bank, and it carries a risk of loss or theft. Sellers need to verify that it’s not counterfeit, and it takes time to do so. In short, physical cash is risky and inconvenient in large amounts.

Join the waitlist!

Be the first to know when DealNow for dealers goes live.

Interested in*
Join the waitlist!

Be the first to know when DealNow for dealers goes live.

Interested in*
Join the waitlist!

Be the first to know when DealNow for dealers goes live.

Interested in*