What Is the Best Way To Pay for a Car?

Buying a car privately should be simple and safe. Yet, many payment methods are risky, slow, expensive, inconvenient, or all of the above. 

Let’s cut through the confusion and find the best way to pay for a car—securely and quickly.

Should I Pay With Physical Cash?

Physical cash has one big advantage: you pay on the spot. No waiting for funds to clear, and no transaction fees. But for high-dollar car sales, cash payment is a bit risky and awkward. Here’s why:

  • Awkward counting: The seller and you will each need to count and recount.
  • Counterfeiting risk: The seller will need to inspect each bill to verify that it’s not counterfeit. They may even want to go to your bank with you to get the bank’s guarantee.
  • Time-consuming: All of this takes a lot of time.
  • Loss or misplacement: If, for any reason, you misplace your cash before meeting the seller, you’re out of luck with no recourse.
  • Risk of crime: if the purported seller is a criminal, they could be plotting to grab your cash and make a run for it.

If you’re buying an old beater for a couple of thousand dollars, buying a vehicle in cash is fine. But for a $50,000 F-150, you want something as immediate as cash, minus the risk and trouble.

Wire Transfers Require Trust

Wire transfers offer a high level of security and finality. The bank verifies your funds and sends the payment to the seller’s bank account. Wire transfers are great for the seller because they typically wait until the funds clear to hand over the title. 

Here’s why you might want to skip using a wire transfer to pay for your car:

  • Once you pay, you are at the mercy of the seller. If the payment takes several days to clear, they might disappear with the vehicle and your money.
  • Bank transfers only occur during regular business hours. If you pay near closing time, the seller might not receive the funds until the next day. Again, delays.
  • You need the seller’s bank details, which can be awkward to ask for.

The best way to pay with a bank transfer is to confirm the seller’s identity and meet them at your bank early in the day to initiate the payment. If you don’t like prolonged inconvenience or placing your trust in a stranger—but you do like the finality and certainty of a bank wire—then DealNow will be your best friend.

What About Cashier’s Checks?

Cashier’s checks are a tried-and-true avenue for two strangers to get a high-value transaction done. Your bank places a hold on your funds and guarantees that your cashier’s check is good.

A smart seller will insist on meeting you at your bank so the bank can guarantee the check’s legitimacy, given the prevalence of cashier’s check forgeries. 

If you’d rather skip the inconvenience and reliance on banker’s hours, read on. 

Should I Use Payment Apps?

Peer-to-peer payment apps such as Venmo are great for splitting bills. They’re inadequate for large fund transfers. Here’s why:

  • Transaction limits: Most payment apps cap out and can’t handle large transactions. If you split the payment over multiple days, you’ve delayed your purchase and exposed yourself to increased hassle.
  • Security reviews: A large transaction may trigger a security review and lock up your funds for a while.
  • Fees: If you insist on using a payment app, the seller may require you to cover their fees. Oftentimes they are percentage-based and incurred on transactions and withdrawals.
  • Lack of assurance: None of these mobile applications protect you against a seller who accepts your money and changes their mind.

Let’s look closer at the shortcomings of payment apps for vehicle transactions.

PayPal

If you have a verified PayPal account, you can send up to $60,000 in a single transaction. If the sales price is less than that, you’re golden—if you don’t mind the fees.

PayPal charges a 2.9% + $0.30 fee for goods and services. For a $60,000 vehicle, that’s almost $1,800. If the seller insists on using PayPal, they might be charging you more to cover their fees.

PayPal will allow you to dispute transactions for up to 180 days. So you do have some protection against untrustworthy sellers.

Venmo

If you have a verified personal Venmo account, you can send up to $4,999.99 per transaction. If you’re buying a 1997 Civic, go for it. For most cars, $5K won’t cut it. 

Cash App

If you have a verified personal Venmo account, you can send up to $4,999.99 per transaction. If you’re buying a 1997 Civic, go for it. For most cars, $5K won’t cut it. 

Zelle

Zelle doesn’t allow high enough fund transfers to be viable. Its limits vary by bank but are usually around $2,000 to $5,000 per day.

A Better Payment App

Save those other apps for pizza night. DealNow gives you the immediacy and convenience of a payment app without limits on the amount of funds you can send.

DealNow | Safe and easy vehicle transactions

Credit Cards Aren’t Worth the Hassle

Most sellers won’t be set up to accept direct credit card payments. Unless they own a client-facing business, they won’t have the equipment. Even if they do, they probably won’t want to mix personal and business transactions.

To pay by credit card, you (and the seller) will need to use an intermediary payment processor. Stripe is the most common. Buying a Toyota Tacoma for $35,000? If you pay via Stripe, brace yourself:

  • You pay: $35,000
  • Stripe’s cut: $1,015.30 (2.9% + $0.30)
  • Seller receives: $33,984.70

If you’re advocating for a credit card payment, the seller will probably expect you to cover the fees. There go any cashback rewards you were hoping for.

Can I Pay With Cryptocurrency?

Cryptocurrency is fast, peer-to-peer, and secure. It’s also difficult to navigate and incredibly volatile. Unless you’re familiar with the world of blockchain, steer clear. Here’s why crypto is not for the masses:

  • Despite the hype, crypto isn’t user-friendly. Both parties need digital wallets and a solid understanding of how transactions work.
  • While blockchain is secure, user error isn’t. One wrong digit in a wallet address, and your payment could vanish forever.
  • Crypto values can swing wildly, even within hours. Your $20,000 car sale could be worth $18,000 or $22,000 by the time the transaction clears.
  • That crypto payment might come with an unexpected gift: a capital gains tax bill. The IRS classifies crypto as property, so you’ll owe taxes on any appreciation.
  • You can’t deposit crypto at your bank. The process of converting it to cash involves fees and delays.
  • The legal landscape around cryptocurrency is still evolving. Future regulations could impact how you can use or exchange your crypto payment.

If instant, secure payments made by mobile are what you’re looking for, we’ve got a solution for you.

A Better Way To Pay for a Car

DealNow combines escrow-like security with the immediacy and convenience of a peer-to-peer mobile app. No more counting bills, waiting for payment confirmation, or trading sensitive data—just quick, secure transactions from your mobile device.

Here’s why DealNow is the best way to pay when buying a car:

  • No transaction limits: Whether you’re buying a Kia or a Bugatti, DealNow can handle it.
  • Bank-level security: Your funds are protected with advanced encryption and held in an FDIC-insured account.
  • Instant funds: No more waiting for checks to clear or wire transfers to process. With DealNow, your payment is processed immediately.
  • Low, flat fee: Unlike percentage-based fees that force you to overpay, DealNow charges a nominal flat fee per deal.
  • Freedom from banker’s hours: DealNow works 24/7/365. Want to do your deal at 11:55 on New Year’s Eve? Weird, but okay. You’ll get your funds.
  • Identity verification: You and the seller undergo thorough identity checks, reducing the risk of scams.
  • Escrow-like safeguards: Both parties complete a digital bill of sale in our mobile app, which protects both of you and gives the seller assurance that they can safely transfer the title (because they know that you’re legally obligated to follow through with payment).
  •  

DealNow is more than a payment app—it’s your partner in simple, secure, and stress-free auto transactions. Here’s how it works:

  1. Create a DealNow account and verify your identity.
  2. Find a car you like (on online marketplaces, social media, or through word of mouth).
  3. Let DealNow verify the seller’s identity, then use in-app messaging and scheduling to set up the test drive. 
  4. Queue your payment and electronically sign the bill of sale with the seller.
  5. Receive the title and keys and enjoy your new ride.
  6.  

It’s that easy. After you’ve used DealNow, you’ll never want to buy a car any other way.

Physical Cash FAQ

What is the safest payment for a private car sale?

The safest payment option is DealNow’s secure payment system. DealNow provides instant, verified transfers of up to $1 million, unlike cash (which can be counterfeit or stolen) or checks (which can bounce). The funds are securely held and instantly released upon completion of the sale, protecting both the buyer and seller throughout the transaction.

Private car sales can be risky. Here’s how to protect yourself:

  • Take your time: Don’t rush into a purchase. Carefully inspect the car and take it for a test drive.
  • Verify details: Check the VIN against the title and vehicle history report.
  • Beware of pressure: Walk away from sellers using high-pressure tactics. A fair deal doesn’t need a hard sell.
  • Use secure payments: Avoid cash or easily faked forms of payment. Use a secure platform such as DealNow that protects both buyers and sellers.
  • Trust your gut: If something feels off, it probably is. There are plenty of honest sellers out there.

Remember, a little caution goes a long way. With DealNow, you get built-in safeguards and a secure payment process, making your car-buying experience safer and smoother.

Most states require the buyer of a car to pay sales tax on the purchase. Besides sales tax, there aren’t any other tax implications when buying a car.

Here’s what you need to know about tax implications for vehicle purchases in a general sense. 

  • Sales tax: You will owe applicable state sales tax on the purchase price. The rate varies by state but averages 4% to 7% of the car’s fair market value.
  • Sales tax exemptions: Research what exemptions are available in your state. Some states waive tax if a transaction is between immediate family members, or if the registrant is a religious organization, government body, or some other exempt status.
  • Private sellers don’t collect tax: You will pay sales tax at your local Department of Motor Vehicles when you register the car.
  • No income tax: A private-party transaction is not taxable income, so no income taxes are owed.
  • No gift taxes: Even gifting the car to someone later does not generally incur gift taxes unless it’s a very expensive luxury vehicle. Individual state rules differ.

If you’ve found a good used car and are ready to buy it, an escrow service can help the private-party transaction go smoothly. Unfortunately, traditional escrow services are expensive and inconvenient.

DealNow gives you escrow-like safeguards in the palm of your hand. Where an escrow company charges hefty fees, DealNow only charges a small, flat fee when sending payments.

Buying a car from a private seller isn’t just faster—it’s often cheaper too. Here’s why:

  • No dealer fees: Skip those pesky documentation charges that can run into hundreds of dollars.
  • Skip the middleman: Dealerships buy low and sell high. With private sales, you’re cutting out that profit margin.
  • More choices: From barely-driven luxury cars to well-loved classics, private sellers offer a range of options.
  • Better sales prices: Whether you’re eyeing a pristine new model or a fixer-upper, private sales typically mean lower sales prices.

Bottom line? Private sales let you stretch your car-buying dollar further.

Join the waitlist!

Be the first to know when DealNow for dealers goes live.

Interested in*
Join the waitlist!

Be the first to know when DealNow for dealers goes live.

Interested in*
Join the waitlist!

Be the first to know when DealNow for dealers goes live.

Interested in*